Horizon Kinetics bought Texas Pacific Land four times this week. Every single purchase landed below $512. By Friday the stock sat at $444, down 13.2%. The fund added 2 shares Monday at $512, then 1 share Wednesday at $475, another Thursday at $467, and a final share Friday at $444. Four buys, four days, and the stock fell the entire time. This isn't a hedge fund catching a falling knife. Horizon Kinetics owns 3.5 million shares of TPL, a position they've built methodically over 16 buys in the past year. They've sold zero. The stock trades at 73 times earnings with 60% net margins, missed estimates by 50% last quarter, and sits 19% below its 52-week high with an RSI of 35. Oversold by every technical measure. Horizon Kinetics kept buying anyway. The rest of the week was selling. $83M walked out the door across 30 transactions. Zero discretionary buys. The only buyers were Horizon Kinetics picking up shares of a stock in free fall, and 10 Simon Property Group board members executing what looks like a coordinated equity grant exercise. Not a single insider at any company chose to put discretionary cash into their own stock this week. The selling wasn't panicked, it was methodical. Pre-planned sales dominated, but the cumulative direction tells you something about where insiders think we are in the cycle. Energy led the exodus. Three insiders moved $21.5M out of ConocoPhillips, Halliburton, and Williams Companies. ConocoPhillips CEO Ryan Lance sold $15M on Monday, 14% of his position. Pre-planned, but the stock dropped 1.8% by Friday anyway. Halliburton CEO Jeffrey Miller moved $6.3M the same day, also pre-planned, also a meaningful chunk at 14% of his holdings. The stock fell 5.6%. Williams Companies' general counsel added another $143K to the pile on Friday. The pattern over the past 30 days is even sharper: 35 energy insiders selling $2.4 billion, 16 buying $8,816. That's not a typo. Sixteen buys totaling less than $9K. The entire energy sector has been one long exit since March began. Technology was worse in dollar terms if not in scale. $35.6M left six companies, and not one insider bought a share. The standout was Monolithic Power Systems, where General Counsel Saria Tseng sold $25.9M on Monday. The stock gained 2.3% by Friday, which tells you the market absorbed the sale without blinking. Seagate's CEO moved another $8.4M the same day. Ciena's SVP sold $700K on Tuesday and watched the stock climb 22.7% by Friday, the biggest gainer of the week. Pre-planned sales, every one of them, but here's the 30-day view: 90 tech insiders selling $461M, 5 buying $10.6M. A 43-to-1 ratio in dollar terms. If insiders saw tech as undervalued right now, someone would be buying. Nobody is. Alphabet had two insiders selling Tuesday. President of Global Affairs John Walker moved $2.5M, 15% of his position. Frances Arnold, a board member, sold another $28K. Both pre-planned. The stock closed Friday up 7.8%, so neither left money on the table in the immediate term. But zoom out: Alphabet trades at 25 times earnings with 33% net margins and beat estimates by 6.8% last quarter. The stock sits 16% below its 52-week high, below both its 20-day and 50-day moving averages, with an RSI of 47. By every metric, this is a quality company trading below recent highs. Two insiders sold anyway. An 8-K filed April 2 disclosed a departure and appointment of certain officers. The timing is worth noting. Utilities had three insiders selling $2.7M this week, and the 30-day pattern is extreme: 21 sells totaling $4.7 billion, 2 buys totaling $93,549. Health care saw four insiders move $4.7M with zero buying. Financials had $6.3M in selling against $439K in buying, a 14-to-1 ratio. Consumer staples, consumer discretionary, and communication services all saw 100% sell-side activity this week. Across every major sector, the direction was identical. The Simon Property Group buys Friday looked like buying until you read the filings. Ten board members collectively purchased $413K worth of shares, all on the same day, all at $186.53. The stock closed Friday at $188.67, up 1.1%. That's not ten people independently deciding Simon Property was undervalued. That's equity compensation being exercised on a schedule. It shows up as buying in the data. It's not signal. Interactive Brokers reports earnings April 14. Director Lori Conkling bought $1,710 worth of shares Friday. The stock closed flat. The company trades at 29 times earnings. One small discretionary buy 11 days before earnings is technically a vote of confidence, but $1,710 doesn't move the needle. It's the only insider trade this week where someone put their own money behind their own company ahead of a known catalyst. That fact alone tells you how rare discretionary buying has become. Texas Pacific Land reports earnings sometime this quarter. Horizon Kinetics just bought the stock four times in five days while it dropped 13%. They own 3.5 million shares and haven't sold once in twelve months. When the only real buying all week comes from a fund catching a falling stock in a sector everyone else is abandoning, you're looking at conviction or contrarianism. Monday's Daily Filing will show whether anyone else joins them. |